Channa's Notes

Ten issues / building blocks

  1. State-wide Structure of Government: Executive and Legislature
  2. Sub-state Structure of Government: Executive and Legislature
  3. The Courts
  4. Electoral Framework
  5. Constitutional Rights
  6. Foundational Principles of Government
  7. Local Government
  8. Procedures for Constitutional Change
  9. Independent Bodies
  10. Symbols of Culture and Identity

Channa's comments in bold below give an idea of how they could be interpreted as strong or weak. Ideas which will eventually be reflected as spatial relations or symbolic forms that become part of the final object that is the perception of a particular constitution by an individual critiquing it. This will have a grade of 1-10. 1 being week and 10 being strong.

BB1

State-wide Structure of Government: Executive and Legislature

The basic unit is the territorial, political and legal construct called the state. The essential institutions for a state to function is an executive which can govern, and a law-making legislature.

The ability of the state to function more or Less efficiently will depend of the relationship between the executive and the legislature. The nature of governance will depend on the actual relationship between the two. If the legislature is powerful then the voice of the Governed people are likes to prevail while the executive being powerful may mean that the voice of a privileged few prevail.

1. for a strong executive ( ex a fully fledged monarchy with a board of minsters or privy council to advice and make laws)

10. for a strong legislature. ( a fully fledged Democracy with a non-executive head of state)

Spatial Manifestation

Here space shows a relationship between the executive and the legislature, through a spatial connection to each other. the relationship between the two range between one in end the legislative space dominates or controls access to the executive to one in which the executive controls access and dominates movement into and through the space representing the legislature. This is manifested in the kind of openings between the places and the connecting spaces between them being direct or convoluted.

BB2

Sub-state Structure of Government: Executive and Legislature

No all states may have a sub-state level of government, although most increasingly do. These may be fully-fledged democratic structures, or merely centrally appointed institutions. In the latter case, there may not be a separate legislature. Sub-state structures may serve to manage societal pluralism within the state, to democratise decision-making, or merely for administrative convenience.

Substructures and their effectiveness is based on the relationship it has with the state. On one end they will be governed by democratic decision making at the level of the substructure (10) while at the other end of the spectrum will be mere administrative convenience. (1)

Spatial manifestation

Here the relationship of spaces should be about the spatial connection between the main state structure and the substate structure. It may be manifested in the way the spaces representing the executive and the legislative in the Sub state structure relates to the main legislative and executive spaces. In a situation in which the Substate structures are independent it may show that the these support and hold up the super state structure whereas in a situation where they are only organs of government to spread out the writ of the main state structure they will appear linked and even held from above by it.

BB3

The Courts

The judiciary is often separate if not independent of the executive and legislature. Its role may be minimal – as a dispute resolution mechanism among individuals and between individuals and the state – or it may be more maximal – serving as a guarantor of the constitution against the executive and the legislature.

To define how this will relate to the final objective of how these various aspects of the constitution works within a given situation, relationships need to be established. In the case of the courts it will then be about understanding its relationship to the executive and the legislature. In could at one end be dictated to by the executive or legislature, or justice is meted out by the executive or the legislature or both ( as in an absolute monarchy) (1) , and at the other end remain totally independent as a guarantor of the constitution against the executive and the legislature (10)

Spatial Manifestation

Here the space representing the Judiciary will at one end be completely integrated with that of the legislature/executive and at the other be completely independent but connected to the two spaces representing the executive and the legislative with possibly one way entrances where the Judiciary has independent access to the executive/legislature and controlled it.

BB4

Electoral Framework

There can be no democracy without procedures and institutions for elections. But even some formally non-democratic states have limited provision for elections.

The electoral framework is a fundamental relationship between the people and the body of governance. In any democratic process, The level of democratic freedom in a structure of governance will be essentially defined here. At one end all officials in the structure of governance structure would be elected by the people (10) on the other, the whole structure of governance would be wielded by a person or body whose authority ultimately comes from violent submission often clothed in the idea of divine right (1)

Spatial Manifestation

Here is the very foundation of the relationship between the governed and the government. At one end the electoral system is the foundation of all elements of the government where the choice remains totally and wholly with those electing. At the other end, the foundation of the elements of government are perhaps non- existent, or pinned down violently from above.

BB5

Constitutional Rights

Every democratic constitution nowadays includes some statement of rights, although there are wide variances with regard the scope, range and depth of their protection, and of course their practical implementation.

Spatial Manifestation

The relationship of the rights and the nature of the rights offered to the governed by a constitution defines in many ways the relationship between the executive and the legislature. Where rights are most highly respected and open ( 10) then the nature of the relationship defined for the executive, legislative and judicial in BB1 and BB2 will tend towards (10) as well and the contrary would be true on the other.

BB6

Foundational Principles of Government

Most constitutions would set down the basic principles of government, such as the separation of powers. This may be expressed in purely functional terms, merely describing the roles of the institutions of government and their interrelationship. Increasingly however these take on an overtly normative character in the way they are articulated in constitutions. In this sense, they go beyond functional allocation of roles to a statement of values by which the society is to be governed.

The statement of values of how a state is governed, will define the relationship between the State and the People and the rights guaranteed by the state and enshrined in the constitution. This then clearly sets up the relationship between the executive , legislative and judicial arms of the state

Spatial Manifestation

Spatially this will manifest itself in the way each arm of government relates to each other. an open and multidimensional set of spaces will indicate values that are more about individual liberty and the guarantee of it and more convoluted relationship may indicate values that support one or other interests of different groups in Society where individual liberty must succumb to those of different power groups be they nationalist, racist, religious or others.

BB7

Local Government

This is not essential but is extremely widespread.

Where fill democratic freedoms of local government with decentralisation of power is seen in a structure of governance, then the more likely that BB1, BB2 and BB5 will tend towards (10). Where local government structures are weak, or non-existent these will all tend to (1)

Spatial Manifestation

This will be similar to the spatial manifestation seen on BB1, BB2 and BB5 and perhaps fine tune the exact nuances of the spaces that connect between the main instruments of government.

BB8

Procedures for Constitutional Change

All constitutions set down procedures for their amendment, although these are extremely heterogeneous.

Procedures for constitutional change will directly relate to the process by which the constitution was first made. Where a democratic procedure may have been adopted in the making of the constitution such a similar set up would be manifested in the process of change. This then related to both BB4, BB2 and BB1. The ability to have a high level of debate and discussion in the processes of change would give this a (10) while to this processes and at the other extreme is constitutional changes without recourse to public discussion and engagement (1) In its manifestation in real terms a process by which the legislature is clearly made to adopt and open and inclusive process for discussion though the power of laws a review of the actions of the legislature and the executive by the Judiciary is very important here.

Spatial Manifestation

The elements here will define the nuances of the relationship between the main instruments of government and also the nature of the foundation of these instruments of government.

BB9

Independent Bodies

The use of de-politicisation institutions is becoming more and more widespread (some would now call them ‘the fourth pillar of government’) in weak political cultures to ensure independence, integrity, and professionalism in the delivery of public services, as well as to pursue certain normative goals such as human rights.

Spatial Manifestation

Independent bodies are clearly a pressure element that brings to bear on the three most important pillars of government to respect the rights and laws and regulations defined by the constitution. The process of defining their constitution should be one that relates them for their formation to the representatives of the people who are represented in the legislature, but once appointed, checks and balances may need to be in place. This may involve a clear relationship between the legislature and the Judiciary.

BB10

Symbols of Culture and Identity

Although often of little or no legal force, constitutional symbols are powerful devices of building a cohesive polity around a constitution. In preambles or other preliminary provisions, it is quite common to see constitutions making reference to the society’s past, present, and future, its nature and culture, its values and aspirations, and appeals to unity and diversity.

This may not have a specific spatial Manifestation. However may have a more material manifestation and could perhaps be included in some form of objective attribute. Often these values are associated with the executive- more specifically the head of government or state as embodied within them and one who is inspired by them in their life and this setting the example to the rest of the population.

Spatial Manifestation

While spatially this will have a clear relationship to the executive and access to it is through the legislature and executive, they are more an objective manifestation that will define a final form to the object. Objective forms such as overarching ones to define inclusivity, high pointed forms to to define unity, or more etc. The choice of what the overall appearance of the constitutional edifice is what here may be changed to reflect something that is not the reality of the spaces within but something that the controlling elements of government might want to be seen as.

Other considerations

Is there a particular relationship between each these that are or should be defined in terms of constitutional law that governs the making of a constitution? What is an ideal state in which all 10 building blocks would be represented and in what form?

"Building" the Constitution

From the reading of this documents it appears the physical/ spatial manifestation will very likely be 6 physical elements representing the following:-

The people - represented as a foundational element

The legislature - represented as a spatial element

The executive - represented as a spatial element

The Judiciary - represented as a Spatial element

The local Government bodies - represented as spatial element

The fourth estate - Represented as a binding element

Thus, the constitution s not represented as 10 literal building blocks but by 6 building blocks whose primary relationship will define the basic nature of the object. The other four items will be represented in modifying those relationships by fine tuning the spatial, foundational or even connective nature of the main blocks.

The 6 main architectural elements and their primary relationships are designed to have 10 separate variations to the relationships. These will then further modifiable by 10 variations brought about by the other 3 elements of the building blocks. The final element of symbolic culture will also have 10 variations which will define what the outward manifestation that person looking at teh edifice thinks it wants to project.

The architects will model each of the elements and 10 relationships each can have with the other 5. means 60 variations fro each main element and thus 60 X 6 = 360 models. these are then further modified by 3 other elements each. Thus the 360 models can have 30 further variations. 1188 models which can have 10 further variations 11880 model/variations in the computer!! Is this possible. ??

choices may be made by the user by marking their choice on a bar marked 1 to 10 for each element and the choice of model with then come out.

Another possibility is that the 10X10 + 100 variations are modelled separately and its location within a bigger framework of basic relations between the three main items of governance; Legislature, Executive and Judiciary, and the governed, thus four elements is defined. This way, each persons choice, will automatically be placed in its assigned location. and the final result is then printed.

This is another model for the software makers to consider and of course my own architectural modellers to do too.